Excerpt from Smith, P.H., Labbok, M., & Chambers, B. (Eds.) (2017). Breastfeeding, Social Justice, and Equity. Amarillo, TX: Praeclarus Press.
Substantial evidence exists documenting the superiority of breastfeeding and breastmilk for mothers, babies, and society. In 2011, the Surgeon General identified improving breastfeeding rates as a priority for the nation, and particularly those with disparate rates (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2011). The Healthy People 2020 Breastfeeding Objectives call for an increase in the proportion of infants that are ever breastfed to 81.9%, and for 60.6% to continue to breastfeed for 6 months (Healthy People, 2013). Only 58.9% of Black American mothers initiate breastfeeding, and 30.1% continue for 6 months (Healthy People, 2013). Persistently a disparity, African-American breastfeeding rates might be deemed one causal factor for the high morbidity and mortality rates for this population (Cottrell & Detman, 2013). African-Americans consistently have some of the highest rates of diabetes, breast cancer, asthma, and obesity (Adler et al., 1994).
Black mothers face barriers to breastfeeding that are both complex and multi-dimensional. Whether a mother breastfeeds or not is influenced by intersectional factors, including cultural beliefs related to infant feeding practices. To increase breastfeeding initiation and continuation rates in this population, cultural beliefs must first be explored so that culturally appropriate interventions can be designed. Previous studies suggest that a woman’s infant feeding decision is made based on factors, such as her perception of women’s roles as a mother, her life experience, and perceptions of societal response and support (Bentley, Dee, & Jensen, 2002). The aim of this study was to describe low-income, Black Americans’ beliefs and attitudes about breastfeeding.
This was a qualitative descriptive study. Eight focus groups, each consisting of four to seven participants were conducted: five focus groups consisted of pregnant and/or parenting women, two groups with grandmothers, and one group with fathers (Table 1 [in the book] displays the demographics of the participants). Participants were recruited from the community, including a community outreach center, churches, beauty shops, and a barber shop. A semi-structured interview guide was used to elicit discussion. Participants were asked to discuss:
- what they heard about breastfeeding,
- what they thought about breastfeeding,
- what made breastfeeding easy,
- what made breastfeeding difficult, and
- to identify how and when they made feeding decisions and who influenced their decisions.
Participants received a $20 gift card to compensate for their time. Audiotapes were transcribed and analyzed using qualitative content analysis. Demographic data was analyzed using descriptive statistics.
Perceived breastfeeding benefits
There are numerous health benefits associated with breastfeeding, such as decreased risks of obesity for children who are breastfed, and reductions in rates of breast and ovarian cancer for a mother who breastfeeds (World Health Organization (WHO), 2013). All participants could describe the benefits of breastfeeding for both mothers and babies. All stated that breastfeeding was “the best way to feed your baby.” In addition to the health benefits, mothers mentioned that breastfeeding allowed them to “be able to bond better with [their] child.” Fathers included financial benefits, stating that “it beats paying for formula. Why get formula when you’re getting something better and it’s free?” All participants stated that they would recommend breastfeeding to everyone. Mothers and grandmothers noted that breastfeeding was more convenient than formula-feeding.
You didn’t have to wash a bottle. You didn’t have them crying until you made the bottle. You have to wake up in the middle of the night but it’s easier to lay them with you and nurse them.
Perceived breastfeeding difficulties
Black women steadily have some of the lowest breastfeeding rates among all ethnicities and races, which may be attributed to several breastfeeding barriers (Beal, Kuhlthau, & Perrin, 2003). Mothers described a number of breastfeeding difficulties, including health issues (mother and/or infant), pain, insufficient milk, employment, additional family responsibilities, and infant temperament. Fathers identified similar difficulties adding that lack of previous breastfeeding experience was problematic. Grandmothers added that breastfeeding “can be a lot of work.” Grandmothers also believed that a need for a nutritious diet could make breastfeeding difficult:
So momma has to be careful, because if you like to eat, you know, certain things, you just have to watch it until you finish breastfeeding.
Despite the perceived difficulties, all participants stated that they would recommend breastfeeding to everyone.
Breastfeeding beliefs and practices
Mothers described making the feeding decision in late pregnancy, or after their babies were born. All participants said that health care providers, both physicians and nurses, were most influential regarding infant feeding. Participants also mentioned that WIC classes and school health classes presented positive breastfeeding messages and images; however, they were “few and far between.” Many mothers described receiving discouraging comments about breastfeeding from family members, usually the maternal grandmother.
My grandmother and my mother both told me not to breastfeed because I guess they didn’t do it; they bottle-fed.
The findings reported are consistent with past literature on Black breastfeeding beliefs and attitudes (Jefferson, 2013; Leigh 2010). Relationships between African-American women’s life experience, and their attitudes and perceptions of infant feeding exist. Findings from one study suggested that positive breastfeeding attitudes, and greater probability of breastfeeding intention, were observed among participants who knew someone with a higher level of education who had breastfed their infant, as well (Jefferson, 2013). Similarly, women in our study stated that they felt more likely to continue breastfeeding when they had the support of their family and peers, or knew someone who breastfed. Consistent with our findings, another study concluded that women also felt that their own community and society, including their environment and mass media, influenced their choice to breastfeed or bottle-feed (Leigh, 2010). According to Leigh, women felt that there were more frequent images of women bottle-feeding than breastfeeding. This, in turn, influenced the perception of infant feeding for the mother, regardless of whether the mother being portrayed in the media was feeding formula in the bottle, or if the bottle contained expressed breastmilk.
“Social support, infant health, bonding, and breastfeeding strategies are enabling factors along with mothers’ personal commitments to continue breastfeeding beyond 6 months” (Gross, 2014, p. 70). Spouses and maternal grandmothers play a significant role in a mothers’ infant feeding decisions. Infant feeding is a cultural mainstay in Black families; therefore, having an understanding of factors that enable mothers to breastfeed successfully would assist stakeholders and health care providers in giving support.
Breastfeeding peer support has consistently been identified as aiding in breastfeeding success in low-income mothers (Anderson, Damio, Young, Chapman, & Perez- Escamilla, 2005; Chapman, Morel, Damio, & Perez-Escamilla, 2010; Gross, 2014; Raisler, 2000). Through the use of peer breastfeeding support persons, organizations, such as WIC, should continue to work to normalize breastfeeding, as well as provide clients with culturally familiar resources. Peer counselors can serve in churches, schools, and community health care centers. Media, such as local radio stations and billboard advertisements, could also promote breastfeeding in those communities. Businesses, such as beauty salons, and community spiritual centers, such as churches, could become “mother-friendly” establishments that promote breastfeeding support (Texas Mother-Friendly Work-Site, 2011).
In order to achieve WHO’s (2013) aim to increase the global rate of exclusive breastfeeding at 6 months to at least 50% by 2025, comprehensive education and breastfeeding support must be afforded to all mothers. This includes African-American mothers who experience greater breastfeeding disparities than other ethnicities. Implementing the Ten Steps from the WHO-UNICEF Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative, particularly in hospitals that serve African-American women, could support women’s infant feeding choices in the prenatal, intra-partum, and postpartum periods (WHO, 2013). Researchers should work to gain a better understanding of both micro- and macro-level contextual factors that affect African-American mothers. Having a greater knowledge of the complex experiences of breastfeeding among Black women will help to improve infant feeding disparities. This, in turn, will further advance the development and implementation of interventions that target the multifaceted ways in which African-American women are successful with breastfeeding.